Jason and Kylie Kelce in Philadelphia on Sept. 8, 2023.Photo:Lisa Lake/Getty

Jason Kelce and Kylie Kelce attend Thursday Night Football Presents The World Premiere of “Kelce”

Lisa Lake/Getty

Love actually isn’t all around at the Kelce house!

Jason Kelceand his younger brotherTravis Kelcewere quick to denyKylie Kelce’s holiday-movie request when she called into the Wednesday, Dec. 4, episode of theirNew Heightspodcast.

“I’m just calling because … I don’t have a need for relationship advice,” Kylie, 32, quipped in her message. “What I do need is to nominate a movie for the next movie review. I think it’s the holiday season, and thatLove Actuallyis a tremendous movie that you could really sit down with your significant other and enjoy.”

Kylie, who’scurrently pregnantwith her and Jason’s fourth child, added some playful hints: “It’s not like one of your significant others hasn’t asked you to watch it multiple times and you said ‘no’ every time, so this would be a great excuse to get you to watch it. I hope you take this into consideration.”

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human-interest stories.

Jason Kelce; Hugh Grant and Martine McCutcheon inLove Actually(2003).New Heights/Youtube; Peter Mountain/Universal/Dna/Working Title/Kobal/Shutterstock

Jason Kelce Shuts Down Kylie’s Holiday Request; Hugh Grant, Martine McCutcheon Love Actually - 2003

New Heights/Youtube; Peter Mountain/Universal/Dna/Working Title/Kobal/Shutterstock

But Jason — who is already dad to daughtersWyatt, 5,Elliotte, 3, andBennett, 21 months — didn’t seem to be familiar with the 2003 holiday classic.

“Is that withGerard Butler, is that what that is?” the former NFL star asked, with Travis, 35, quickly correcting him, “No, we’ve gotHugh Grant,Liam Neeson.”

“Liam Neeson, is that like aTakenfilm?” Jason asked. “I’d have been in if it wasTaken.”

But upon learning thatLove Actuallywas, in fact, nothing like aTakenmovie, Jason changed tactics, saying, “I think we can both probably agree we’re not doingLove Actually. We’ll open it to a fan vote as always. There’s no favoritism played here, even for my own wife.”

Kylie wasn’t done pushing her request, though, telling her husband and brother-in-law that she was willing to appear on the podcast if they choseLove Actuallyas their film to review.

The PEOPLE Puzzler crossword is here! How quickly can you solve it? Play now!

Andrew Lincoln and Keira Knightley inLove Actually(2003).Album/Alamy

Love Actutally, Keira Knightley

Album/Alamy

Jason recommended a compromise, suggesting that Kylie review the film on herNot Gonna Liepodcast and offering to appear on her show himself.

However, Travis, whometLove Actuallystar Grantat one of his girlfriendTaylor Swift’sEras Tourshows, admitted that he has recently enjoyed watching the British actor’s films.

“I’m not gonna lie, I’ve watched two or three movies with Hugh since,” the Kansas City Chiefs tight end said, “and I f—ing love all of them. There’s something about knowing the guy, man.”

As for Kylie’s request, after some pressure from their podcast producer, Jason finally suggested a “double movie review” episode includingLove Actuallyas well as a fan pick.

source: people.com